Requests for specific Motley Fool UK boards to be added

[robbelg]

How about a Companies board with a topic for each company discussed?

That's pretty much what's already happening on the "Share Ideas" board in "Sectors & General Shares"

[Degsy67]

Peer to Peer Lending discussion has broken out on the Current Account & Savings board as I feared previously. I suggest this is setup as a distinct board and existing threads are moved to the new board.

Degsy

[melonfool]

Peer to Peer Lending discussion has broken out on the Current Account & Savings board as I feared previously. I suggest this is setup as a distinct board and existing threads are moved to the new board.

Degsy

Does it really matter? The current account board on TMF wasn't used that much so having the three together seems OK?

Mel

[touchnotthecat]

Property investment and Buy to let - not sure what the boards were on TMF

[Gengulphus]

Property investment and Buy to let - not sure what the boards were on TMF

Try http://www.lemonfool.co.uk/viewforum.php?f=13.

Gengulphus

[AleisterCrowley]

Can we have a 'Books' board please

[wheypat]

Instead of Grumpy Old Lemmons/Fools/Men, how about Sour Lemons?

[NomoneyNohoney]

"Yes" to Sour Lemons...

[Urbandreamer]

Can I specifically request that we do not have a board called LOST.

I confess that I did enjoy my time on LOST, but there is a implicit prommise that ANY serious topic will be allowed with no postings being "moderated" or censered.

It is natural that people feel strongly about serious topics, in the past they have been willing to die for them. Naturally posters are blunt and abraisive.
"Moderation", well let us be honest censorship, is a nightmare. Without "moderation" evidence shows that chain reactions lead to a meltdown. Yet, censorship, in any form (ie go to MET), denies the importance of the "serious topic".

Ps, the link of moderation and censorship I hope should be viewed specific to LOST, though I did experience it on other TMF boards. Ie a thread asking about pensions on HYP where I postulated spreading risks by having investment that were not equity based. Yes I believe it WAS censored, not moderated.

PPS sorry for any spelling mistakes or grammer errors.

[PinkDalek]

Can I specifically request that we do not have a board called LOST.

I confess that I did enjoy my time on LOST, but there is a implicit prommise that ANY serious topic will be allowed with no postings being "moderated" or censered. ...

There is no board called LOST and there is every indication there won't be. What we have available is:

"Polite Debate & Discussion" viewforum.php?f=47 which presently contains the sub forums "The Economy" and "Polite Discussions High levels of moderation".

Clariman's views may be found in the locked Topic here viewtopic.php?f=63&t=959 which commences:

"This Board was called "polite discussions" in order to set the tone for debate that we expected. In particular, lemonfool did not wish to replicate TMF's LoST board. However, the topics, the polemic, the ad hominem attacks and general standard of discussion here are not appropriate to this site. ..."

[Gengulphus]

"Moderation", well let us be honest censorship, ...
...
Ps, the link of moderation and censorship I hope should be viewed specific to LOST, though I did experience it on other TMF boards. Ie a thread asking about pensions on HYP where I postulated spreading risks by having investment that were not equity based. Yes I believe it WAS censored, not moderated.

No, there is a big difference between moderation and censorship that is relevant here. Censorship is an attempt to prevent discussion of something happening anywhere, while one form of moderation is to tell you that you need to discuss it in the right place. As long as a "right place" is provided, that's not censorship: it's just requiring posters to post where readers who are interested in the posts can find them and readers who aren't interested in them aren't bothered by them.

On TMF, the "High Yield - HYP Practical" board's topic was "running a HYP in practice" and it was quite specifically not about:

* Running anything other than a HYP (and its definition of a HYP was quite clear that HYPs are invested in shares), so running investments that were not equity-based was not included;

* Issues of what strategy is best - so whether a "HYP + non-equity-based investments" strategy was better than a "HYP only" one was also not included.

But either the "High Yield - Share Strategies" board or the "Investment Strategies" board would have been a perfectly good place for you to post instead, and so telling you "No, you can't post that on High Yield - HYP Practical" was just moderation, not censorship.

Having said that, I strongly suspect that in practice, there will be censorship of some topics on this site. As you indicate, there are some topics about which too many people only seem to be able to be blunt and abrasive. Those can potentially lead to legal battles about defamation - and stooz and Clariman have made it very clear that even the faintest whiff of such a legal issue will make them pull the posts (and clearly that means from anywhere on the site - allowing them on some boards and not others doesn't deal with that reason for pulling them). The net result is that I suspect there will be topics that simply cannot be discussed sensibly on this site.

However, I'm not worried about that censorship, because there are many other places where such issues can be discussed. Indeed, anyone here can set such a site up themselves - stooz and Clariman have recently demonstrated that it's quite feasible to do such a thing! The only difference is a very minor one as far as the site's users are concerned, but a crucial one for the person who sets up the site: that person bears the legal risk rather than stooz and Clariman...

Gengulphus

[midnightcatprowl]

Code: Select all

Can we have a 'Books' board please

Yes please and, if so, could the old TMF 'Book Club' run its discussions as threads in the Books Board? This suggestion is to help avoid having too many separate boards but members of Book Club from TMF have been gathering on Lemon Fool and we are anxious to nominate and vote on some new books to read.

[PinkDalek]

Yes please and, if so, could the old TMF 'Book Club' run its discussions as threads in the Books Board? This suggestion is to help avoid having too many separate boards but members of Book Club from TMF have been gathering on Lemon Fool and we are anxious to nominate and vote on some new books to read.

It may be an idea, for the time-being, to ask Lemonfool (I don't know how to do that other than sending a PM to stooz or Clariman who must, however, be inundated) if they can add "Books" to "Music, Theatre, TV and Film" in the "Interests - Culture, Leisure , Food and Nature" Forum, such that you can, at least, commence a Books Topic there.

Which you can, of course, whether or not Books is in the title. Radio already has a Topic ...

[Clariman]

As I enjoy helping people who have a particular issue, but are otherwise disinterested in a topic, perhaps we could have an easy to find set of boards, available immediately from the front page. I can't see any such board for finance -

Help! - Investents and Financial Products
Help! - DIY
etc

I guess it's all about catering for different audiences.

--
Daytona

We have this in the Lemon-Aid group of boards already. This is similar to "Helpful Fools" on TMF

[Clariman]

Moderator Message:
Locking this topic. In the process of finalising enhanced board structure