Bank and Insurance Prefs Aas a Holding Strategy?
Posted: November 2nd, 2023, 9:24 am
Over the last few months I have been drip-feeding funds into higher yielding equities and investment trusts (of various kinds). In one sense, this tactic has paid off, in that I've been getting cheaper prices (and therefore higher yields) with each subsequent round of purchases. In another, I might have been better off just keeping the powder completely dry and sitting tight.
A possible alternative strategy would be to deploy the capital into bank and insurance prefs (as well as PIBS). The rationale for this approach is that they mainly yield around 7-7.5%, which is above both inflation and short-term gilt rates (or bank deposits). The likelihood is that many of the available options will be called before 2026 via tenders and when/if that happens, investment trusts and equities could have bottomed out. I can see a few risks with this line of reasoning, one of which being that inflation resumes it's upward trajectory which could cause pref yield to increase if base rates look like they might head up also. Has anyone else had similar thoughts about the strategy and/or the risks?
One other potentially related observation. The average yield on most conventional bank and insurance prefs seems to have coalesced somewhere around 7.25%. This is 2% above base rates (5.25%). Two years ago in 2021, the spread was something like 4-5% - which was roughly where it has been since 2014 or so (when concerns over bank failures began to abate). My recall of the period prior to 2007-2008 is sketchy, but the current differential seems comparable to the valuations of most prefs and PIBS from that era. Is the yield for prefs currently mis-priced or have we simply reverted to the mean?
A possible alternative strategy would be to deploy the capital into bank and insurance prefs (as well as PIBS). The rationale for this approach is that they mainly yield around 7-7.5%, which is above both inflation and short-term gilt rates (or bank deposits). The likelihood is that many of the available options will be called before 2026 via tenders and when/if that happens, investment trusts and equities could have bottomed out. I can see a few risks with this line of reasoning, one of which being that inflation resumes it's upward trajectory which could cause pref yield to increase if base rates look like they might head up also. Has anyone else had similar thoughts about the strategy and/or the risks?
One other potentially related observation. The average yield on most conventional bank and insurance prefs seems to have coalesced somewhere around 7.25%. This is 2% above base rates (5.25%). Two years ago in 2021, the spread was something like 4-5% - which was roughly where it has been since 2014 or so (when concerns over bank failures began to abate). My recall of the period prior to 2007-2008 is sketchy, but the current differential seems comparable to the valuations of most prefs and PIBS from that era. Is the yield for prefs currently mis-priced or have we simply reverted to the mean?